|
Measuring Progress - Indiana's Source Reduction and Recycling Rate Drops...The following article was developed from a discussion at the IRC's October 15th Monthly Meeting. Each bullet represents a comment made by an IRC member. Members from all sectors - business, government, individuals and not-for-profits - participated in the discussion. BACKGROUND According to IC 13-19-1-2, "The goal of the State is to reduce the amount of solid waste incinerated and disposed of in landfills in Indiana by 50% before January 1, 2001 through the application and encouragement of solid waste source reduction, recycling and other alternatives to incineration and landfill disposal." WHAT ARE THE LIMITS OF THE CALCULATED RATES?
|
Also in this issue....
News BriefsNRC News
|
WHAT FACTORS AND SITUATIONS ARE NOT ACCOUNTED FOR IN THE CALCULATIONS?
IS THE 2001 GOAL REALISTIC AND ACHIEVABLE?
OPTIONS TO CONSIDER
COMMUNICATING WITH OTHERS ABOUT THIS ISSUE
HOW DO WE COMPARE TO OTHER STATES?
|
November 15, 1998 is the day-America Recycles Day-and Indiana is knee-deep in buying recycled activity.
87 events are happening around Indiana. Get an up-to-the-minute events list (city/county, date, time) on the internet:
www.americarecyclesday.org
www.indianarecycling.org
www.indianarecycling.org/ard.html
And remember, BUYING RECYCLED is a year-round sport!
The mission of the Indiana Recycling Coalition is to support source reduction, reuse, composting and recycling activities in Indiana. To encourage integrated recycling, the Coalition supports buying recycled-content products, and the collection and remanufacturing of recyclable materials. The goal of this support is to conserve our natural resources, decrease reliance on final disposal and to encourage environmental responsibility.
The Coalition provides this support by:
Mercury collections have begun across the State! As of October 10, 140 lbs. of elemental mercury have been diverted from the waste stream for recycling; over 1000 fluorescent bulbs and 140 fever thermometers have been collected. And, some very strange items containing mercury are showing up at collections-including a mercury filled medical device that is designed to go down the esophagus...scary!
At a press conference held at an Indianapolis mercury collection site on October 13, 1998, Lieutenant Governor Joe Kernan urged Hoosiers to make their homes safer and healthier by turning in mercury products for recycling. He said this free collection is a safe way to get rid of mercury without hurting the environment. If mercury is released to the environment, it can pollute our air and water and it can wreak havoc on the food chain, building up in the tissues of fish and other wildlife.
The message is clear: keep our environment clean and our children safe from this toxic threat-RECYCLE your household mercury at a recycling site near you. How does the program work? Each local collection site will bring the mercury containing items to their nearest HUB. The HUB collection sites are:
From the HUB, the mercury is transported to Global Recycling Technologies, Inc. in Stoughton, MA. There the mercury containing items will be demanufactured and the mercury cleaned through a distillation process. The mercury is sold to a mercury switch manufacturer for reuse, and the other components are sold through the appropriate recycling markets.
Have you done the Mercury Search in your home? You may find fever thermometers, thermostats, fluorescent bulbs, clothes irons (with tilt shut-off switches), silent light switches, or a jar of plain old elemental mercury in your home-they all contain mercury and need to be recycled!
Counties across the state are holding mercury collections this October and beyond. Your local solid waste management district has more information about mercury recycling in your area. Or call the Household Hazardous Waste Taskforce 812-349-2115 for more information about the Mercury Awareness Program.
Last spring, the Coalition's Consensus Issue Task Force began to gather information about the role of Indiana's Solid Waste Management Districts and their impact on the goals and objectives of the Coalition (see IRC mission statement on page 1). On February 12, 1998, at the Midwest Waste and Environmental Exposition and Conference, the Task Force hosted a panel discussion titled, "The Role of Solid Waste Districts in Indiana". The goal of this panel discussion was to solicit opinions from business, the general public, legislators, and districts about how Districts were performing. On a broader scale, the Task Force also wondered if districts were accomplishing the original goals of HEA 1240. Forty-two people attended. Although legislators had intended to participate, they could not attend due to an unavoidable scheduling conflict.
Some general points made during this panel discussion include:
Based upon the input from this panel discussion, audience comments, and information from the Task Force members, the following consensus position for the Coalition membership is proposed:
Proposed Statement: Solid Waste Management Districts are an essential part of the State of Indiana's efforts to reach waste diversion goals. Districts provide the framework for the development of source reduction, reuse, recycling and composting programs. These programs are the fundamental tools for accomplishing the goals established by HEA 1240.
A consensus position on this issue is important to the Coalition because the solid waste districts play an integral role in developing and expanding source reduction, reuse, recycling and composting programs in Indiana. Consensus positions must have the backing of the membership to be valid. This combined "coalition" position is what gives the consensus position strength and garners recognition in the legislature and with other partners in waste reduction in Indiana. In the next week or so the IRC will mail out cards soliciting response on the draft statement. Please respond so that support for this and future consensus surveys can have meaningful impact.
From the opening speech by David Kling, EPA's Director of Pollution Prevention, through to the rousing concluding panelists presentations, the First Indiana Pollution Prevention (P2) Conference and Trade Show carried messages of industry and business successes, program achievements, and enthusiasm. The one-day program held at the Valley Vista Conference Center in Greenwood, IN was designed to be an informational and networking forum covering a wide variety of P2 related topics, speaker sectors, and approaches. With some 30 displays, there were ample opportunities for the over 250 attendees to discuss practical solutions and alternatives for toxic use reductions. Among the many guests present were students from several Indiana Universities, including Purdue, Ball State and Indiana University.
The highlight of the day was the formal presentation, by Lieutenant Governor Joe Kernan and IDEM Commissioner, John Hamilton, of the Governor's Awards for Pollution Prevention to this year's six recipients: Cinergy Corporation, Eli Lilly, Tippecanoe Laboratories, I/N Tek, United Technologies Automotive Berne, and Don Seader, WorldWide Automotive. The five larger companies were cited individually for significant air, water, and solid/hazardous waste reduction and for personal leadership. One of the most telling comments by the recipients came from Don Seader, representing small automotive shops (in this case seven employees). His message was simply a heartfelt thanks for considering small shops to be part of the pollution prevention program.
Among the featured speakers of the day were, Bob Towsley of Eli Lilly who presented the technical side of production systems cleaning innovation; Matt Gluckman, EPA Region 5, who discussed the Common Sense Initiative; and Kay Nelson of the Northwest Indiana Forum who added her spin on the public process. John C. Hamilton, Chairman, of the Clean Manufacturing Technology Board; John Chavez, newly appointed IDEM-OPPTA Pollution Prevention Branch Chief; and Vince Griffin, representing the State Chamber of Commerce, each provided their perspective on pollution prevention.
The Conference was co-sponsored by IDEM and Purdue University's Clean Manufacturing Technology and Safe Materials Institute, and was supported by a number of business and industry participants under the umbrella of Indiana Partners for Pollution Prevention. The Partners now look forward to planning this conference to be a yearly event, and to establishing an organizational approach that will ensure sustainability of pollution prevention as a key element of state environmental and economic policy.
Imagine - No doodling. No drooping heads nodding off to sleep. No whispered conversations unrelated to the topic at hand. No escaping out the back at the changing of the speakers. No bolting out the door at the end of a session.
When was the last time you attended a conference that was more interesting 'in' the sessions than beside the coffeepot? The 75 people who attended the Association of Ohio Recycler's (AOR) conference, Zero Waste: You Decide - Fact or Fiction? would tell you - just last month! The Zero Waste sessions were filled with laughter AND heated debate as speakers challenged listeners to really think about the waste they create - and what can be done about not creating it in the first place!
The conference planning committee worked diligently to create an environment of zero waste. Meetings were held with the hotel housekeeping and banquet staff to assure that as little waste as possible would be created by the conference. Attendees saw frequent reminders to "Take only what you need - use all that you take!" And where waste couldn't be avoided - it was measured! A combined total of only 9.2 lbs. of food waste was thrown away. However, a full 55 lbs. of food was taken to a local shelter as coordinated through Northcoast Food Rescue.
If copies of the speakers' materials or information on the topic in general is desired, please call the AOR office at 888-718-6639.
Ink jet cartridge recycling is becoming easier these days thanks to the teamwork of The Indiana Recycling Coalition (IRC) and Enviro Smart/AAA Environmental, Morton Grove, Illinois. In the past year our efforts to divert computer plastics from the waste stream had leveled off. Now a new customer friendly, triangle-shaped dispensing unit is available for display at campus bookstores, office supplies stores and organizations that use significant numbers of ink jet cartridges.
The cardboard dispensers house a roll of plastic, pre-addressed, postage-paid, ready sealed mailing pouches that can be detached, (much in the same way as paper towel dispensers in public rest rooms). A patron pulls out a free pouch, drops his/her used cartridge in the pouch, and drops it in the mail. It is just that simple.
The cartridges are reconditioned, re-filled with ink, and then sold in a secondary market. And best of all, the pouches have bar codes on them that credit the IRC to receive a refund for every cartridge that's recycled and in good condition. Unfortunately, not all brands are accepted, but the types of ink jet cartridges that are accepted are clearly marked on the display unit. A sample unit can be seen at the IN Environmental Institute located in the ISTA Building, 150 West Market Street, Suite 520, Indianapolis, IN.
United Airlines Maintenance Facility in Indianapolis and the East Central Solid Waste District have already placed orders for units to be shipped to them. There are no out-of-pocket costs to the user to display the new units but there are some delivery and operational considerations. Direct inquiries to IRC Board Member Jeff Miller at 317-328-1189. So help the environment and raise funds for the IRC in the process!
The Illinois Recycling Association, U.S. EPA Region V, Illinois Department of Commerce and Community Affairs sponsored a Polystyrene Recycling Forum, which was held on October 13 in Chicago. The Indiana Recycling Coalition was a supporting organization for this forum. Plastics industry representatives, recycling haulers and processors, community recycling program managers , and interested persons participated in this day of dialog, summarized below.
Problem #1: When it comes to the PACKAGING GRADE of expanded polystyrene (EPS) that is collected co-mingled curbside, there no longer exists any market for the collected material. Period. There currently is no identified end-user for this material, which is often contaminated beyond acceptable levels during the co-mingled collection process. (Examples include the polystyrene packaging that a consumer finds when he or she unpacks a new electronic item, stereo or computer). However, there IS a stable market for EPS PACKAGING GRADE MATERIAL that is collected from industrial or commercial sources, and which is clean and in large quantities. The clean industrially- and commercially-generated EPS is remanufactured into EPS foam packaging peanuts.
Problem #2: When it comes to the FOOD GRADE of EPS, there is only one company that is accepting the collected material, and they are currently charging $300 per ton, plus transportation costs, to process it before it gets shipped overseas for final use. (Examples include egg cartons, meat trays, fast food containers, school lunch trays, and coffee cups). Programs that are collecting this material are at the mercy of this one market.
Problem #3: Some community recycling program contracts may require collecting, processing and recycling of these EPS materials. Continuing to handle these materials has become very expensive and difficult to market. As a result, many programs have removed EPS from their curbside collections. In some cases, the EPS materials that are curbside collected end up in the "residual stream" (i.e. destined for a disposal facility), because there is no outlet for them, regardless of the cost. Both of these situations can reduce the sustainability of the entire recycling program.
Background: In the early 1990's, the plastics industry made a concerted effort to promote EPS recycling, actively recruiting communities to participate in collection programs. In addition, the industry made a huge financial investment in the formation of the National Polystyrene Recycling Company, located near Chicago. In 1995, EPS recycling peaked. Since that time, even with aggressive efforts, a number of factors have contributed to a sure but steady decline in the recycling of the "problem" EPS materials (co-mingled packaging grade and also food-grade EPS). These factors include: the low cost of virgin PS pellets, the even lower cost paid for recycled PS pellets, contamination and rodent problems, the difficulties in handling the EPS once collected, high overall transportation costs because of the material's low weight, and low demand for new products made from recycled EPS. Although the future is impossible to predict, the current trends indicate that markets will not improve any time soon, and the consensus that came forward from the October 13 forum focused on how to encourage removal of the "problem" EPS materials from curbside recycling programs.
The American Plastics Council and the Alliance of Foam Packaging Recyclers (AFPR) agreed to work with the affected parties to develop user-friendly education materials about this issue, using a two-tiered approach geared toward community and recycling program coordinators and also residents. The AFPR offered use of it's toll-free 1-800-944-8448 number to help answer questions, in addition to including a fact sheet on it's web site at www.epspackaging.org for program organizers to utilize. Several of the key players at the forum agreed to assist in the development of the educational materials. In addition, information on reuse and recycling of foam packaging peanuts can be found at the peanut hotline at 1-800-828-2214.
This overall situation begs the question: How are decisions made about which individual materials are included in recycling programs? When fine-tuning a program requires the surgical removal of a specific material that is no longer viable to accept, how can this message most effectively be communicated, without jeopardizing the healthy part of the recycling program. In other words, how can we work together towards the goal of more effective and sustainable recycling?
The annual conference of the Association of Indiana Solid Waste Management Districts (AISWMD) was held October 28 - 29th in Indianapolis. The "new" Executive Director, Mark Davis, is an "old" friend to a majority of the 125 people who attended. In addition to a reunion with Mark, attendees enjoyed a full conference agenda.
Workshop session topics included; Commissioner's Environmental Court; HHW Education for Children; Brownfield Redevelopment; Web Page Design; HHW Mercury Project; Boards and CACs working together; State Board of Accounts-What you must know; Pollution Prevention; What's new with OSHA; and a legislative discussion section on HEA 1339 and SEA 349.
If you failed to attend, you missed a wealth of information crucial to management of a solid waste district. The AISWMD is currently comprised of 40 paid member districts and conference attendees were present from 40 districts. The conference was coordinated by members of the AISWMD Board of Directors, with great thanks to the Northeast Indiana SWMD and Monroe County SWMD.
The return of Mark Davis to solid waste management issues in Indiana is expected to lead the AISWMD to growth in membership and increased involvement with districts individually and collectively. He summarized his objective simply, "to help districts do their jobs better."
Mark Davis formerly served as director of the Brown County Solid Waste District from 1993-1996, and was president of the Indiana Recycling Coalition and an IRC board member from 1995-1997. For the past 2 1/2 years Mark has worked for PDR Engineers, an environmental engineering consulting firm headquartered in Lexington, Kentucky.
A two-year grant from IDEM for $70,000 funds the position and AISWMD projects. The grant is matched in-kind and with funds from membership dues. Mark expects to travel a lot but will maintain his office at the Monroe County Solid Waste Management District in Bloomington. His voice mail is at 812-349-2117 and his pager number is 888-694-5814. Please consider contacting him for information on becoming a member. The success of districts depends on unity and mutual support of the mission to reduce and properly manage waste generated in Indiana.
What is gleaning? From biblical origins, gleaning is the practice of gathering extra crops that are left in the fields after a harvest. Coupled with food rescue and recover, it denotes the collection and distribution of food to disadvantaged individuals.
Prepared and perishable foods are gathered from a number of sources, including restaurants, caterers, hotels, corporate cafeterias, farms, wholesale docks, farmers' markets, and supermarkets. Anyone can lend a hand at any level, from large restaurant chains donating in bulk, to individuals volunteering time to glean on a farm.
Gleaning groups - 'prepared and perishable food rescue programs' (PPRFP), cleanly and efficiently pick up and deliver the food donations. These organizations are trained in careful food handling and preparation methods. These donations are routinely sent to child-care centers, soup kitchens, homeless shelters, food banks or pantries, all of which serve the needy daily.
The USDA National Hunger Clearinghouse, administered by World Hunger Year, aims to connect people and organizations seeking information about reducing food waste. Congress recently passed the "Bill Emerson Good Samaritan Law" (HR2428) protecting donors for good faith donations of food for free distribution by charitable organizations. Tax credits are also available to donors!
For more information, contact USDA National Hunger Clearinghouse at World Hunger Year, Phone: 800-GLEAN-IT or http://www.iglou.com/why/glean
Copyright 1998 by the Indiana Recycling Coalition
Web Page Design by Cyberville Webworks